In the vibrant world of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern cuisines, two dishes stand out for their irresistible flavors and intriguing similarities: the Turkish Iskender doner or Greek Gyro. These culinary delights, while sharing some characteristics, boast distinct histories, ingredients, and cooking techniques that highlight the rich culinary traditions of their respective countries. This blog delves into the delicious world of Turkish Doner and Greek Gyro, exploring their origins, differences, and why Doner holds a special place in the hearts of food lovers, particularly in Turkey.
What is Turkish Doner?
Turkish Doner, a revered dish in Turkey, is a feast for the senses, known for its succulent meat, which is traditionally beef. The meat is seasoned, stacked in an inverted cone, and slowly roasted on a vertical rotisserie. As the outer layer cooks to perfection, it’s thinly sliced and served, showcasing the art of Turkish cooking. Chicken Doner, a more economical variant, is equally popular for its delicious taste. However, it’s crucial to note that Turkish Doner never includes pork, adhering to cultural and culinary norms. Doner is ubiquitous in Turkey, found everywhere from luxury restaurants with unique presentations to small street-side vendors offering a quick, tasty meal. This accessibility and versatility underscore the mastery of Turks in perfecting Doner.
What’s the Difference Between Doner and Gyro?
The primary distinction between Doner and Gyro lies in their ingredients and preparation. Turkish Doner is traditionally made with beef, though chicken has become a popular alternative for its affordability. Conversely, Greek Gyro primarily uses pork or chicken. The Turkish approach to Doner focuses on the simplicity and quality of the meat, while Gyro often includes a more complex blend of spices.
In serving terms, Turkish Doner showcases its versatility by offering delightful experiences over rice, wrapped in bread, or rolled in lavash, a thin, unleavened bread. Conversely, Gyro usually finds its way to the plate, accompanied by a variety of sides. The cooking techniques diverge significantly; chefs cook Turkish Doner on a vertical rotisserie to ensure even cooking and to concentrate the meat’s flavors. Meanwhile, Gyro cooks on a horizontal spit, a method that delivers a unique texture and taste to the dish.
These differences underscore the unique culinary approaches of Turkey and Greece, with Doner being a proud representation of Turkish culinary excellence. The emphasis on quality meat, simple yet effective seasoning, and versatile serving options make Doner a standout dish in Turkish cuisine. The distinction also lies in the cooking apparatus: the vertical rotisserie used for Doner ensures an even, succulent cook, a hallmark of Turkish culinary tradition.
Is Doner Turkish or Greek?
The origins and cultural significance of Doner, a dish deeply embedded in the culinary traditions of Turkey, often sparks curiosity and debate among food enthusiasts around the world. Recognizing the importance of this dish, one of the foremost experts in Ottoman and Turkish culinary history, Associate Professor Dr. Özge Samancı, was invited to contribute to the book “L’Épicerie Du Monde” published in France. This publication, which chronicles the history of globally recognized foods and dishes from the 18th century to the present, includes a seminal piece by Dr. Samancı on the history of Doner, highlighting its rich cultural and culinary heritage.
What is the origin of döner? Doner or Gyro?
Everyone wonders, “Where did Doner first originate?” Historical accounts provide fascinating insights into its origins. Evliya Çelebi, a leading historian and traveler of the 1660s, described a type of kebab during his visit to Crimea that closely resembles what we know today as Cag Kebabı. This method involves stacking meats horizontally over a fire to cook, offering the earliest clues about Doner. The term and technique of preparing kebabs in various ways, including on spits, in pits, and in tandoors, have been part of the Ottoman culinary practice, tracing back to the Seljuks in Anatolia since the 11th century (Seljuks, a Turkish state established in Anatolia in the 11th century).
Doner Kebab emerged within this landscape of kebab love and culinary expertise, originating in the Ottoman territories. The evolution from horizontal to vertical cooking methods occurred as the latter proved more practical for urban settings. One of the most intriguing pieces of evidence regarding Doner’s popularity is a black and white photograph from 1855, depicting a Doner chef in Istanbul standing in front of a vertical rotisserie. This indicates that by 1855, Doner had become a widespread food item in Istanbul.
When Does Doner First Appear in Ottoman Turkish Cookbooks?
The first mention of Doner in Ottoman Turkish cookbooks dates back to 1883, in a cookbook titled “Ev Kadını” (Housewife). Interestingly, the dish was referred to as “Izmir Kebabı” in this venerable text, which provides a recipe for Doner under this name. Between 1900 and 1915, travelers exploring the Ottoman lands documented the presence of Doner not only in Istanbul but also in other cities, such as a record from Amasya in 1915.
In summary, Doner represents a significant cultural heritage that has evolved from the Ottoman kitchen to modern Turkish cuisine, interpreted in delicious forms by master chefs over centuries. When discussing Doner as a cultural heritage, it’s essential to mention Iskender Kebab, one of the most delectable variations of Doner. The İskenderoğlu family introduced Iskender Kebab, a specialty of Bursa, as a unique flavor that enriches the culinary diversity of Turkey. Through these insights, it becomes clear that Doner is not just a dish; it’s a storied part of Turkish culture and history, distinguishing it from its Greek counterpart, Gyro, and underscoring its Turkish origins.
The Global Presence of Doner
Doner, a flavor cherished not only in Turkey but around the world, enjoys recognition under various names across Europe and globally. For instance, in France, people more commonly know doner as ‘gyros’. In Mexico, it goes by ‘al pastor’, and in Lebanon, it’s known as ‘shawarma’. But why does this diversity in naming exist?
Interestingly, a few years back, the World Food Atlas, published in France, almost declared doner a national food in Germany. This recognition comes from doner’s widespread popularity and consumption across Europe. French expert Pierre Raffard shares the story of doner’s entry into Europe, which occurred in stages. Although the first widespread doner shops appeared in Berlin in the 1970s, its European journey began earlier. In the 1920s, Greek immigrants from the Ottoman territories introduced the first doner to France, initially opening doner shops there and calling it ‘gyros’ among themselves. As doner entered each new country, it adapted to local tastes, finding its unique form. You can also consult Wikipedia for examining academic information.
Doner or Gyro in Europe?
After the 1961 labor law, Germany saw a significant influx of Turkish immigrants, marking the second wave of doner’s spread. Initially favored in Berlin’s Turkish neighborhoods, doner quickly became popular for its practicality, speed, and deliciousness. Soon, doner shops started appearing frequently. Cities like Berlin, Brussels, Amsterdam, London, and Paris all host doner shops, albeit under different names. As mentioned, each country interprets doner in its way.For instance, you can encounter curry-flavored doner in Germany, whereas in France, especially at venues offering ‘gyros’, the staff inquire about your preferred sauce for the doner. Sauce options include tzatziki, hummus, or harissa. The French, fond of sauces, typically spread the sauce inside the bread before adding doner slices and salad. Traditionally, Ottoman cuisine prepared doner with mutton, considered more desirable. Today, Turkey also uses beef alongside mutton. Over time, variations like chicken doner have emerged, and in Greece, pork doner exists.
The story of doner abroad sees a third wave with the Lebanese. Lebanese migrants to South America introduced doner, known there as ‘al pastor’, to Mexico and beyond. This version, made from pork and marinated in pineapple juice, localizes and gains popularity for its unique flavor.
In short, doner today stands alongside pizza, pasta, and hamburgers as a globally recognized and preferred flavor. Doner’s appeal lies in its versatility, offering both luxurious and quick, on-the-go eating options, showcasing its universal appeal and adaptability to different cultural tastes and preferences.
You can also check out the following blog posts related to the topic.
Turkish or Greek?: Which food belongs to which culinary culture?
Cacık: Belongs to Turkish or Greek Cuisine?
Turkish Baklava: A magnificent work of Turkish culinary heritage
Turkish Yogurt: The Fermented Miracle of Turkish Culture